Should You Have Your Oak Staircase Painted or Keep the Wood Natural?

Oak staircases are common in homes throughout McHenry County, and I’ve painted many of them over the years. The golden and orange tones of oak can start to look very dated when the rest of the home has newer flooring, different trim colors, or a more modern interior.

 

Aside from kitchen cabinet painting, having an oak staircase painted is one of the interior updates that dramatically changes the look of a home. If you’re unsure whether to paint yours or keep the natural wood, there are a few things worth considering before making your decision.

The first floor section of an enormous oak staircase I painted in a townhouse in Crystal Lake, IL.

How Painting Changes the Appearance of Oak

One of the biggest differences between painted oak and natural oak is the appearance of the wood grain. Oak has a prominent grain pattern that some don’t mind, though most homeowners I’ve worked with are happy to paint oak instead of leaving it natural.

 

A More Uniform, Updated Appearance

Painting an oak staircase significantly reduces the visible grain, and though some of the natural texture can still be seen, the overall look is quite different from natural or stained oak.

 

I’ve found that homeowners who want to move away from the traditional golden oak appearance often prefer a painted finish. Paint helps the staircase blend in with updated trim, walls, and other interior features rather than stand out because of its original wood color.

Primer and paint will hide most of the natural wood grain on your oak staircase.

When Keeping the Natural Oak Look Is the Better Choice

If you like the natural grain and character of oak, painting may not be the best option for you. Paint changes the appearance of the wood permanently unless you later decide to strip the finish.

 

I would think about what you like and dislike about your staircase. If you want a smoother, more consistent appearance that works with the rest of your home, painting is the way to go. Staining the staircase a different color might be the better option if you want to preserve its natural look.

A painting project in Cary, IL where the customer wanted only the spindles painted white.

Choosing Between Different Painted Staircase Looks

You don’t necessarily have to paint every part of an oak staircase. Depending on the look you’re after, painting just certain components can be a good middle ground between an entirely painted staircase and keeping everything natural.

 

Painting the Spindles and Keeping the Handrail Natural

White spindles paired with a natural wood handrail and newel posts are a popular combination. The white lightens the appearance of the staircase, while the natural wood preserves some of the warmth and character of the oak.

 

The image above, which features a painting project in Cary, Illinois, is a good example. My customer wanted to reduce the amount of golden oak showing without completely hiding it. Painting only the spindles white was the perfect balance for contrast.

Painting the Handrail While Keeping the Wood Spindles Natural

You can also take the opposite approach and paint the handrail while leaving the spindles and posts natural. Whether this works well depends on the staircase’s design and how the wood color coordinates with the surrounding trim and flooring.

 

I would consider the staircase as a whole before choosing which parts to paint. The goal is to create a combination that looks intentional rather than like certain sections were painted simply to cover up an unwanted color.

A staircase painting project in Crystal Lake, IL that incorporated two colors for contrast. 

Painting the Entire Staircase

Painting the entire staircase can give it a completely different appearance, whether you choose one color or combine two. The image above of one of my staircase painting projects shows how two colors can make a huge difference.

 

White spindles paired with dark brown or black handrails can create an attractive combination that works well in many homes. You can also paint the entire staircase one color for a more uniform appearance. Using one color also reduces labor costs because it’s less time consuming.

 

Using Brown Paint for a Wood-Tone Appearance

Brown paint can provide a darker, warmer appearance if you want to move away from the traditional orange tones of oak without choosing a light color like white. Wood-tone colors also help hide dirt. 

 

It’s important to understand that brown paint will also hide most of the natural wood grain, so if you want to preserve that, staining the wood a different color is the better option.  

Can Painting an Oak Staircase Help When Selling Your Home?

If you’re preparing to sell your home, an oak staircase may be worth considering as part of your interior painting updates. This is particularly true if the oak wood tones look out of place alongside newer flooring, updated wall colors, or white trim.

 

Making the Interior Look More Cohesive

A staircase is one of the first things people notice when entering a home. When its color clashes with updated surroundings, it can make the interior feel less coordinated.

 

Painting the staircase turns it into a showpiece and gives the entryway a more modern appearance, and it will also add some value to your home while helping it sell faster. 

Priming an oak staircase spindle before painting in this Huntley, Illinois, home.

What to Consider About Preparation and Painting Costs

Painting an oak staircase involves a lot more than simply applying a new color. The preparation and detailed work are important parts of achieving a durable, professional-looking finish with perfectly straight paint lines where colors meet.

 

Proper Preparation Is Essential

Painting an oak staircase involves a ton of prep work. When I paint an oak staircase, I start by cleaning and sanding it before applying two coats of an appropriate primer-sealer. I then apply two to three finish coats to achieve an even, smooth appearance.

 

Painting directly over the existing wood without the right preparation and primer can lead to adhesion problems. Oak staircases also have many edges, corners, and detailed areas that require careful attention when priming and painting.

Finished oak staircase in a Huntley, Illinois, home, with the stairs and walls below protected during the project.

The Amount of Detail Affects the Cost

The scope of the project makes a difference in how much work is involved. Painting only a handrail is considerably different from painting dozens of spindles, newel posts, risers, and other staircase components.

 

Two-color paint jobs also require additional time because the lines where the colors meet need to be clean and precise. Protecting the steps and surrounding flooring is another important part of the process, especially when the stairs are carpeted or the flooring below needs to be protected.

When Keeping the Natural Oak Makes More Sense

Although I’ve painted many oak staircases in the Crystal Lake area, I don’t think every staircase needs to be painted. Natural wood can still look great when it complements the home’s flooring, trim, and overall style.

 

When You Like the Natural Grain

If you appreciate the character of oak and like the way it looks in your home, there’s no reason to paint it just because painted staircases are popular. Natural wood can provide warmth and contrast, particularly in homes that have other wood finishes.

 

When You Want to Change the Color but Keep the Wood

If the main thing you dislike is the orange or golden tone, consider whether having your staircase restained is a better fit. Changing the stain color will allow you to achieve a different appearance while retaining the natural grain.

 

Like painting, refinishing oak isn’t a simple process, and the results depend on the existing coating and the condition of the wood. However, it’s worth considering if maintaining a genuine wood appearance is important to you.

Get an Estimate for Painting Your Oak Staircase

If you’re in the Crystal Lake, IL area and you’re considering having your oak staircase painted, I’d be happy to talk with you about your project. I provide free estimates for interior painting projects in Crystal Lake, Huntley, Lake in the Hills, Algonquin, Mchenry, and Cary.

 

Contact me today to schedule an estimate. I’ll personally look over your staircase, discuss color options, and provide a free estimate based on the work involved.

Call Matt
847-845-6876