Before I recommend painting a kitchen’s cabinets, there are several things I look at to determine whether it’s a good investment for the homeowner. Some cabinets can be painted with the right preparation, while others may have problems that make painting a poor choice.
After painting hundreds of kitchens in the Crystal Lake area for two decades, I’ve learned that the best results start with knowing what you’re working with before the project begins.
If you’re considering having your kitchen cabinets painted, here are some things I recommend thinking about before you hire a painter.
I painted these kitchen cabinets in Huntley, Illinois, near Rainsford Drive.
Water Damage, Warping, and Bubbling
Water damage is one of the biggest reasons I might advise a homeowner against painting their existing cabinets. Prolonged exposure to moisture can damage wood, cause MDF to swell, and compromise the materials that make up cabinet doors and frames.
If the material is deteriorating, painting over it won’t solve that problem. If the damage is extensive, replacing the affected cabinets may be a better investment than painting them. However, if only one or two doors are damaged, replacing them for a paint job may be a practical solution.
Replacement doors are available online in a variety of styles, and it’s sometimes possible to find doors that closely match the style of your existing cabinetry. This can allow you to keep the cabinets that are in good condition while replacing only the pieces that need attention.
Bubbling or warped cabinet door panels are things I look for when evaluating kitchen cabinets for painting.
I also pay close attention to cabinet door panels that are warped, bubbling, or separating. These imperfections can be surprisingly difficult to see on dark, stained cabinets, but they often become much more noticeable once the cabinets are painted.
When I visit a home to provide a cabinet painting estimate, I inspect the door and side panels carefully. I use a flashlight held at an angle to the surface so that highs and lows in the panel’s profile are easier to see. This helps me identify bubbling or warping that might otherwise go unnoticed.
Older cabinet doors with minor warping issues can usually be fixed through sanding and patching, but if I find doors that are too warped or cracked, I let the customer know it’s best to replace them if possible or skip the painting altogether.
This peeling thermofoil drawer shows how the vinyl shell can separate from the MDF underneath, especially around areas exposed to heat and moisture. I check for this type of damage because painting over failing thermofoil is not a reliable long-term solution.
Are Your Cabinets Made From Thermofoil?
Thermofoil cabinets require special consideration because they aren’t constructed the same way as wood cabinets. Thermofoil doors generally have an MDF core covered with a thin vinyl material. Over time, heat and moisture can cause that vinyl covering to curl at the seams.
Although some paints can be used on properly prepared thermofoil, I don’t recommend painting it because if the vinyl begins to fail after the cabinets have been painted, the new paint will fail along with it.
But if you’re still considering having your thermofoil cabinets professionally painted, make sure the painter is using primer and paint that can be used on that material.
Before having your kitchen cabinets painted, it’s worth considering whether other updates would help achieve the look you want. In this Crystal Lake, Illinois, kitchen, the homeowner replaced the countertops and lighting before I painted the cabinets, allowing those changes to be part of the overall kitchen update.
Do You Like Your Kitchen’s Cabinet Layout and Style?
Before investing in cabinet painting, take a step back and consider whether you’re happy with the kitchen itself. Do you like the cabinet layout? Is there enough storage? Are there certain doors, sections, or features that make the kitchen feel dated?
Paint can dramatically change the color and appearance of your cabinets, but it won’t change their shape, layout, or functionality. If you don’t like the way your kitchen is designed, painting everything as it currently stands may not give you the result you’re hoping for.
The good news is that you don’t necessarily have to replace the entire kitchen to make meaningful improvements. Sometimes, a few carefully chosen modifications can make a big difference before the painting begins.
For this kitchen in Crystal Lake, Illinois, the homeowner replaced the arched upper cabinet doors with a more modern style before I painted the cabinets, updating the overall look while keeping the existing cabinetry.
Small Cabinet Changes Can Make a Big Difference
I’ve worked with many homeowners who made modifications to their cabinetry before having me paint it. For example, a customer in Crystal Lake, Illinois, replaced all of her upper cabinet doors before I painted them.
She didn’t like the arched design of the original doors because it gave the kitchen a dated appearance.
She chose replacement doors made from the same type of wood as the existing cabinetry, but without the arches. That simple change gave the kitchen a more updated look once everything was painted.
For this kitchen cabinet painting project in Lakewood, Illinois, the homeowner chose to replace a glass-front cabinet door with a solid wood door before I painted the cabinets, giving the kitchen a more consistent look that better suited her preference.
Another customer in Lakewood, Illinois, had one of her upper glass cabinet doors replaced with a solid wood door before the painting began. She preferred the consistent appearance of solid doors throughout the kitchen.
These are examples of why I encourage homeowners to think about the entire kitchen before committing to a paint color or scheduling a project. Replacing a few doors, adding cabinets, or making other targeted changes may help you get much closer to the result you want without replacing everything.
If you’re happy with your layout and the cabinets themselves, painting may be an excellent way to update the kitchen. If you’re not, consider whether any modifications should be made first.
Paint does not completely hide the natural wood grain.
Are You Comfortable With the Natural Grain of Your Cabinets?
This is especially important if you have oak cabinets and want them painted. Oak has a prominent natural grain pattern, with deep pores and distinctive lines that remain visible even after painting.
With the right preparation, the deeper pores can be filled to reduce the texture, but paint alone won’t eliminate the natural grain pattern. Even after the pores have been filled, the grain pattern will still be visible. Painted oak won’t have the same naturally smooth appearance as a less grainy wood species, such as maple.
I always explain this to customers before painting oak cabinets because I want them to understand what the finished result will look like. A professionally painted oak kitchen can look beautiful, but it’s important to have realistic expectations about the texture and appearance of the wood.
Dark paint colors make the natural grain pattern of oak more noticeable.
How Paint Color Affects the Appearance of Oak
The color you choose can influence how noticeable the grain pattern is. Darker colors, including black, deep blue, and green, can create more contrast with the grain and make its pattern stand out.
White is often a good choice for homeowners who want their oak cabinets to look less like stained oak that has simply been painted. White creates a brighter, more uniform appearance, and although the natural grain will still be visible, it will be less noticeable.
The amount of oak grain that remains noticeable also depends on the preparation process, and whether or not the grain was filled before painting. Filling helps smooth out the surface but it does not erase the grain pattern.
For this kitchen in Algonquin, Illinois, I painted the cabinets tan at the homeowner’s request rather than going with white. Tan offered a warmer alternative while still giving the cabinets a lighter appearance than the original finish.
Have You Thought Carefully About Your Cabinet Paint Color?
Choosing a cabinet color is exciting, but it’s worth considering how that color will look in your kitchen over time. Cabinet painting is an investment, and most homeowners want a result they’ll be happy living with for years.
I’ve painted cabinets in a variety of colors, including tan, green, blue, and black. These colors can look fantastic in the right kitchen, especially when they’re used thoughtfully. However, most of my customers choose white, and it’s often the option I recommend when a homeowner wants a versatile, timeless look.
White cabinets work well with many countertops, backsplash designs, flooring colors, and decorating styles. White also help brighten a kitchen and make it easier to update the surrounding decor in the future without needing to repaint the cabinetry.
For this basement cabinet painting project in Crystal Lake, Illinois, the homeowner went with black instead of a traditional white or neutral finish. Black cabinets make a strong design statement, but it’s worth considering how a darker color will work with the surrounding walls, countertops, and lighting before making the choice.
Should You Use a Bold Color on All Your Cabinets?
There’s nothing wrong with choosing a bold cabinet color if that’s the look you love. The important thing is to think about how you’ll feel about it several years from now, particularly if you might sell your home.
Strong color trends can change, and a color that looks current today may appeal to fewer buyers later. A future buyer’s preferences are impossible to predict, so I wouldn’t choose a color solely on the assumption that it will increase your home’s resale value.
If you like darker colors but want a more flexible design, consider using them selectively. A dark kitchen island paired with white cabinets can create an attractive contrast without making the entire kitchen feel dark.
The image above of the island cabinets I painted is a good example. My customer wanted to use a darker color but didn’t want to use it on every cabinet. Using it only on the island gave the cabinetry a nice accent color for subtle contrast with the main color.
You could also use a darker color on the lower cabinets while keeping the upper cabinets white, or introduce a contrasting color in a separate butler’s pantry. These combinations allow you to enjoy some personality in your kitchen while retaining a more neutral overall appearance.
Ultimately, choose a color you’ll enjoy living with. Just keep in mind that if you select a very bold color throughout the kitchen, you may eventually decide to repaint the cabinets or change the look again when your tastes or circumstances change.
What Type of Cabinet Coating Will Your Painter Use?
This is one of the most important questions to ask when comparing cabinet painting estimates. Not every paint is designed for the demands of kitchen cabinets.
Cabinet doors are handled frequently, and the surfaces are exposed to grease, food spills, cleaning products, moisture, and everyday wear. A coating that works well on ordinary walls is not suitable for cabinetry.
I’ve spoken with homeowners who received estimates from painters planning to use products that I would never choose for a cabinet painting project. One customer told me that a competing estimate included using wall paint on her kitchen cabinets.
Wall paint isn’t designed for the same demands as a true cabinet finish. Using an unsuitable product can increase the risk of scuffing, sticking, and premature finish failure.
Some painters use quality trim and door enamels in satin or semi-gloss finishes, and these can be suitable choices with the right preparation. I used enamel for my cabinet painting projects many years ago before switching to pre-cat lacquer.
Kitchen cabinets in Huntley, IL that I spray-painted with pre-catalyzed lacquer.
Why I Use Pre-Catalyzed Lacquer
For my cabinet painting projects, I use pre-catalyzed lacquer from Sherwin Williams. The product I use is designed for wood cabinetry and furniture applications, and it can be tinted in a wide range of colors.
I really like using pre-cat lacquer because it provides a hard, durable finish on cabinets with excellent resistance to stains and everyday wear. It also dries quickly, which helps me keep the project moving without unnecessary delays between finishing the doors and installing them.
When you’re collecting cabinet painting estimates, ask each painter what product they plan to use. Find out whether it’s specifically intended for cabinetry, how it will be applied, and what you should expect in terms of durability and care.
Don’t assume that two estimates are comparable just because both painters are offering to paint the same cabinets. The materials and processes behind those estimates can be completely different.
Kitchen cabinet paint prep can make your kitchen unusable.
How Will the Painting Project Affect Your Kitchen?
It’s also worth considering how the project will fit into your daily routine. Your kitchen is one of the most frequently used rooms in your home, and you probably don’t want to be without it for longer than necessary.
Ask your painter how the work will be organized, where the doors will be painted, and how much time the kitchen is likely to be disrupted.
Because I spray cabinet doors in my shop, I can complete much of that work away from the home. The frames are prepared and sprayed on-site, with the surrounding kitchen protected during the process.
I can usually finish the spraying of cabinet frames in a single day, but every project is different, so I don’t promise the same timeline for every home. Some projects simply take longer to finish.
Make sure the painter gives you a realistic timeline and explains when the doors and drawers will be removed and reinstalled. It’s better to understand the expected schedule in advance than to be surprised by how long the kitchen is unusable.
For this kitchen in Huntley, Illinois, I painted the existing oak cabinets, giving the homeowner a way to change the appearance of the kitchen without replacing the cabinetry.
Let’s Talk About Your Kitchen Cabinets
If you’re considering having your kitchen cabinets painted in Crystal Lake, Huntley, Algonquin, Lake in the Hills, Cary, Woodstock, McHenry, or another nearby suburb, I’d be happy to take a look at your kitchen and discuss your options.
I’m Matt, the owner of Advantage Painting Services, and I’ve been helping homeowners update their homes since 2009. I personally evaluate every cabinet painting project and handle the painting myself, so you can discuss your kitchen directly with the person who will be doing the work.
If you’re unsure whether your cabinets are good candidates for painting, that’s a great place to start. I’ll assess their condition and explain what I recommend for your particular kitchen.